
Have Perfect Order, Chaos Rising and Pitch Black Releases Flopped?
, 8 min reading time

, 8 min reading time
After the incredible success of Ascended Heroes, many collectors expected the following releases, Perfect Order, Chaos Rising, and Pitch Black to continue that momentum.
If you've spent any time in Pokémon Facebook groups, Reddit, YouTube or your local card shop over the last few months, you've probably noticed the same conversation.
"These new sets just don't feel the same."

After the incredible success of Ascended Heroes, many collectors expected the following releases, Perfect Order, Chaos Rising, and Pitch Black to continue that momentum.
Instead, many fans feel the excitement has cooled.
But has it?
The answer is actually more complicated than simply calling these sets "flops."
The biggest reason the later sets feel quieter is because Ascended Heroes wasn't an average Pokémon release, it was an exceptional one.
It arrived with:
It created genuine Fear Of Missing Out (FOMO).
When a set sells out everywhere, everyone wants it.

Once collectors experienced that level of excitement, every following release was inevitably compared against it rather than judged on its own merits. Several market commentators point to Ascended Heroes' unusually strong chase lineup and sustained post-launch demand as the benchmark that made subsequent releases feel quieter by comparison.
One factor that's often overlooked is simple economics.
2026 has been packed with Pokémon products.
Collectors have had to choose between:
Instead of buying six booster boxes from one release, many collectors are now buying one or two from several different releases.
That naturally spreads excitement across the year rather than concentrating it around a single launch. Analysts have noted that collector spending has become more spread out across the Mega Evolution block and anniversary products, reducing the urgency around individual releases.
Historically, the biggest Pokémon sets usually have one defining card.
Think:
Perfect Order featured attractive artwork and a balanced card list, but many collectors struggled to identify a single card that justified opening case after case of product.
Without that headline chase, hype naturally slowed.
That doesn't necessarily make it a bad set, it simply makes it a slower-burning one. Several commentators specifically cite the lack of one dominant chase card as a major reason Perfect Order generated less launch excitement despite positive artwork and accessibility.
Chaos Rising is perhaps the most misunderstood release.
While social media may have suggested enthusiasm was fading, several indicators showed strong demand:

In other words, Chaos Rising wasn't necessarily lacking hype, it was simply more focused around one standout Pokémon rather than broad excitement across the whole set.
By the time Pitch Black released, many collectors had already opened:
Four major releases in a relatively short period naturally create fatigue.
Collectors begin asking:
"Should I wait for the anniversary set instead?"
Rather than rushing to buy immediately, many became more selective.
This creates the appearance of weaker demand even when overall sales remain healthy.
Another important change is supply.
Over the past few years The Pokémon Company has worked hard to reduce scalping by increasing print runs and keeping products available for longer.
Ironically, this makes launches feel less exciting.
When shelves remain stocked for weeks instead of hours:
From a collector's perspective it can feel like a set has failed when, in reality, it has simply become easier to buy.
YouTube and TikTok have fundamentally altered how collectors judge new sets.
Every release is immediately compared with:
If a set doesn't immediately produce £500+ cards or instant sell-outs, many creators label it "mid."
That narrative spreads quickly, even when actual demand remains solid.
Many collectors now judge a set almost entirely by:
But Pokémon sets aren't designed solely for investors.
Perfect Order, Chaos Rising and Pitch Black all include:
History has repeatedly shown that many sets initially dismissed by the community later become highly regarded once they leave print.
Subscribe to our emails